Communication and Heartbreaking

BeccaDuine

New member
I feel rather horrible to create an account just to ask for help, but I needed some place for input.

I moved in with my best friends (A married couple)last year. I needed someplace and they needed some extra help. I've done a lot, at least they've said, to help them get their own lives started on track again. It took a while, but we all ended up falling in love with each other.

Things were great the first few months, but things got rocky fast. See, one half of the couple, we will call her Rinae, is a transwoman. This doesn't actually bother me, as i dated a transwoman previously, and beyond that I majority had boyfriends, so being intimate with her was no problem. But, the other half, Sonya, is biologically female. She's been a new experience to me, and it's taken me a long while to get use to how to be intimate with her. She... Didn't take to that well and complained often. Rinae and I stopped being alone together as much to help her not have a comparison while my relationship grew more with her, but she kept linking things on communication, saying I didn't talk to her enough, and that things should be more equal still. She ignored all comments on these poly-help pages of not all the relationships will develop the same...

She wasn't wrong on myself not talking to her much, though. See, Rinae and I are close in age. We share a lot of interests and play with words and enjoy talking circles around each other. She was also there as an ear when Sonya got upset at me and I didn't know why. I've gotten better at asking Sonya directly, but she hasn't developed out of ranting to Rinae about me or bottling things up until they go out of hand... A majority of what was even wrong had to do with trying to be alone with Rinae (Sonya had a habit of joining in so we kept having to wait weeks before we had that relationship focused on), despite us both having time with her already, that I wasn't going "as far" with her as I would with Rinae, that I hadn't been talking to her (Ahem, fixed on this end), and that Rinae wasn't sleeping in bed with us (Medical reasons).

Things had been better for a while, though. I thought, at least. I had been initiating more with Sonya, and I thought that our relationship had been growing pretty well and was on an even plain with mine and Rinae. Our sex lives all took a hit when I started training for work for three weeks and was out of the house for 14 hours, but still, things were good. I had tried to set up things on the weekends, which resulted in me just sleeping in the middle of the bed while they were on their computers... But I had found settings up time together in advance was a great way to keep things obviously equal.

Anyway, my training ended about two weeks ago. I tried for the first week to get either girl, even so much as a cuddle. Rinae rejected me on a fair ground of being too ill, but Sonya had also, stating she had just not been in the mood to. It was... odd. She's not the type to refuse sex. She's taken sleeping medication, and still found the energy. I had still tried to not think anything of it. I had also taken it as what was said, and that things between her and Rinae slowed down as well, and I was willing to wait until she was normal and using them both as an indicator. I had no idea of to ask "Are you horny now?" Without getting my head bumped for annoyance...

After that first week, I did have a moment with Rinae. I didn't think anything on it, because I had thought we were past the point where we had to constantly ask permission. I found out last night that I had been wrong. Sonya broke down after Rinae had told her. She complained that I again didn't iniate anything with her, and when I tried to point out the past, she brushed it off with "Yeah, just one time!" It was every complaint she had thrown at me before, with no reason. I communicated my feelings. I hid nothing from her. I loved making her happy, which she described as a "chore" for me. She said she didn't want to do anything sexual because she could lie to herself and say everything was fine. That had been upsetting to me enough, not knowing how to calm her and point out why she was wrong and what she was forgetting, but it went on to her throwing out the condoms, the things I need with no active birth control to do anything with Rinae.

That had been a tipping point, leading to me snapping and leaving after being pushed to say something when I couldn't process anymore. Rinae later told me Sonya had said that's why she never said anything to me, with Rinae pointing out that this happened because she waited too long to say anything. In any case, it didn't take long for me to calm down and I told to Sonya after, pointing out what I wanted to and explaining myself. She got sheepish in a moment when I explained the waiting for her and Rinae to do things again, with a response of they've been doing things for those 5 weeks anyway.

I... Stopped talking to her at that moment. I didn't want to yell again. She didn't want to have sex with me or me to have sex with Rinae, to keep things "even" in her head, but... she was still able to sleep with her?!

I haven't been able to talk to Sonya after. This behavior has me ragged trying to piece together her complaints. I've talked with Rinae on things. We've both noted that Sonya keeps pushing and pulling things to a V instead of the triangle (Pushing me away from her, pulling Rinae and me just to her and apart). Their relationship has also been strained emotionally lately, and it seems the only healthy relationship left is mine and Rinae's, despite everything else, and it hurts us both to be caught in the middle. We went over fixes, things we still plan on talking over with Sonya, but the one we fell on most that made us both cry was me no longer being with either. We don't want that, but it's all that makes sense.

If you can survive all that, here's my questions:
Is there anything that I could say to Sonya during this talk we plan?
Would breaking up be such a bad idea? (This is just opinion, since... not letting the internet rule my life and all)
Any plans on how to help here...? Any? We've been together for a long while... they've both made me happier than I've been, but... I'm worn and we need help.

Sorry if I'm a bit wordy... I've been up well over 24 hours now.
 
I am sorry you are having to endure Sonya's mindfuck. (Sorry, I can't think of a better term right now.)

I was in a triad with a male / female couple. Without going into a long, drawn out story, suffice it to say the female reminds me a lot of Sonya. Facts did not matter her; the only thing that was "real" to her was how she felt. As an example, the male and I invited her to go for a walk. She declined. Later she accused of us excluding her. WTH? Unfortunately, that was but one example among many.

If Sonya is like the female in my story, nothing will fix the situation because she is not reasonable, and her grasp on reality is tenuous at best.

I am sorry.
 
Hi BeccaDuine,

As an alternative to breaking up with Rinae and Sonya, how about just taking a break from your relationship with them for awhile. Give yourself a few months to pull yourself together, for Rinae and Sonya to make repairs in their dyad, and for Sonya to cool down and reconsider her irrational words and actions. After a certain amount of time has passed, all three of you might have a better idea of whether you think it's worth giving the triad relationship another go.

I think Sonya's insistence on everything being equal is a big mistake. Triads don't work that way. Something's always going to be uneven. I suppose you could say that to Sonya but I don't know whether she'd see reason or red.

Oh and try to get some sleep. :(
With sympathy,
Kevin T.
 
Thank you both. I got some sleep, barely any, but I'll take it. Thank you for the worry.

With Sonya... Some of her constant comparing things is understandable, even though it's not excusable. She does have depression, being treated with both medication and counseling, but that hasn't really helped things.

I've also pointed out things will never be equal. Just how see was with Rinae is a good example. Equal seems less what she wants, and more the balance being to her...

I'll talk over the break thing. It might be the best option. Admittedly, that still seems like breaking up, tough...
 
Good luck and make the best decision you can. It's not an easy situation.
 
"Feelings not facts" is a cognitive distortion. We all might have one here or there but is this chronic? Does she have other ones?

I get a sense of "keeping score" with sex share and time share.

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/in-practice/201301/50-common-cognitive-distortions

Is there anything that I could say to Sonya during this talk we plan?


Ask if she can accept that things are not a "race" and things are not going to be "equal" -- her pressure to make them so it causing problems in letting things naturally unfold. See if her words match her actions.


Would breaking up be such a bad idea? (This is just opinion, since... not letting the internet rule my life and all)


I get that relationships have some normal up and downs, but I don't want super duper up and down drama roller coaster stress. If this is hitting the chronic drama zone, I would break up and date easier people to be with. I am not up for stressy.


Any plans on how to help here...? Any? We've been together for a long while... they've both made me happier than I've been, but... I'm worn and we need help.


From the sound of it, you have been dating a year. To me that is not long. It's one cycle of seasons.

Yes, in the past they inspired happiness in you. That is good memories, but PAST. Nobody is a mind reader -- so predicting FUTURE is not useful here.

That leaves being PRESENT in your today. What's going on in the present time? Conflict. Because Sonya wants to run the triad according to her time table, rather than letting things unfold naturally and accepting each individual is unique, and that makes each pairing between individuals unique.

(S + R) is not the same as (S + you). Those dyads will unfold as they will.

S also has to deal with (You + R) being another dyad. And not be comparing how (You + R) unfolds to how (S + you) or (S + R) are going.

Would Sonya prefer that it be a "V" with her as the hinge? Is that what this is about?

Galagirl
 
Last edited:
So, we all finally had our talk. Sonya didn't want to hear another option except having a break for now. She wants to try to have herself fixed. It's horrible that in order to help not trigger her more, Rinae and I also have to have a break. i'm looking to move out next month. Thank you all for the advice.
 
So, we all finally had our talk. Sonya didn't want to hear another option except having a break for now. She wants to try to have herself fixed. It's horrible that in order to help not trigger her more, Rinae and I also have to have a break. i'm looking to move out next month. Thank you all for the advice.

Is there a time limit on the break? I ask because people with cognitive distortions as severe as Sonya's rarely act on the declaration that they want to fix themselves.

Anyway, I am very sorry.
 
There isn't, and watching Rinae after, I feel things need to be spoken on more. Should there have been one discussed?
 
This story sounds familiar to me. Did Sonya post here to complain too?

The whole situation between the three of you is about sex sex sex, who is doing whom, and how much everyone gets. Not much room for genuine affection and caring there, if that is the main focus. Yuck.

Well, my advice is to get away from that kind of crazy. Too much drama and insecurity. I think your plan to move out is in your best interest. If I were you, I'd leave without a glance back. End it with both of them, find a place to live, and look for relationships where you feel valued, respected, and heard.
 
I honestly wouldn't know if she had... If you could find that and message me, I would be able to tell...

And it... does seem that. Sonya also has said it's been just generally not wanting Rinae and myself to even be alone together... Which has lead to asking for time alone just so two for cuddles and talking doesn't become three... Maybe sex has been the easier thing for her to express her problems through? I don't know... I'm not her and can't honestly say there...
 
Moving out sounds good.

Agreeing to a dating break indefinitely not so much. Sounds too snooze tag to me.... Like avoiding dealing with things.

I like time frames that are measurable. A break for two weeks is measurable. Until I have my therapist appt on the 21st is measurable. I understand a time out in conflict resolution for heads to cool off but that is different than avoiding.

Focus on moving out. Then sort this out... Even if the solution is to break up because of drama.

Galagirl
 
Well, I can talk to them both on the duration, if there is to be one.

I have also found out Sonya does come one this site (I was met with a "Am I Sonya?" Oops...)
 
Well, it happens. Sometimes it's a good thing; it gets things out on the table. And, Sonya has an opportunity to post her side of the story.

It would help if there were some kind of fixed duration that all three of you could live with. For example, if ten years is the shortest duration Sonya can offer, that might be longer than you'd want to put your life on hold. A certain number of months seems more doable.
 
Back
Top