Polyamory.com Forum  

Go Back   Polyamory.com Forum > Polyamory > General Poly Discussions

Notices

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 07-29-2014, 04:31 PM
poly6 poly6 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 58
Default Arguments against

What are all of the arguments against polyamory that you've heard in your time and what would be your rebuttal.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 07-29-2014, 04:37 PM
MsChristy's Avatar
MsChristy MsChristy is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: East Coast
Posts: 87
Default

Obviously people will always think you are cheating on one of your partners or that you are being unfaithful. I always make it clear that all involved are aware of what is going on and ok with it.

I am sure if I ever told my parents (which I am never going to do), they would tell me I am sinning.
__________________
--------------------------------------------------
MsChristy- married female
C-my husband
H-my partner
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 07-29-2014, 06:14 PM
poly6 poly6 is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 58
Default

How do you hide this from your parents? Don't they ever come to visit or anything?
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 07-29-2014, 08:58 PM
Emmy37's Avatar
Emmy37 Emmy37 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 117
Default

1) Are the kids OK with it?
Yup, they love her as much as we do.

2) Am I OK with it?
Yup, I'm more than OK with it. I've never been happier in life than I am now.

3) How do you share your husband...I could never do that....I'm way too needy in a relationship.
It's good that you recognize you couldn't do it. I advise you never try it.
__________________
Bisexual, 38 yr old female, in a triad with Bud-a 32 yr old, straight male and Sweet Lady-a 38 yr old, bisexual female.

More about me here. Includes writings, artwork, music, Facebook page and blogs.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 07-29-2014, 09:09 PM
KC43 KC43 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Location: Massachusetts
Posts: 587
Default

I'm obviously not MsChristie, but on the subject of parents finding out or not...

Not all people in a polyamorous relationship share a household. Hubby and I are legally married and live together with my daughters from my first marriage. He and I were monogamous for 5 years before we chose to open our marriage, and then I met Guy and we moved to a polyamorous V.

But Guy doesn't live with us. He doesn't even live *near* us. So anyone who comes to visit isn't going to find out in any way that we have a polyamorous situation. In fact, my 16-year-old doesn't even know, and she lives with me.

I've encountered the "you're cheating on your husband" reaction--ironically, the people who have said that to me are swingers who have multiple *sexual* partners, but apparently consider me a cheater because I'm in love with Guy.

The other one is "Why did you bother get married if you were going to have sex with other men?" Um... because marriage isn't all about sex, it's about having a life with someone. And I'm too high-maintenance for one man to manage a life with on his own. (That last sentence is complete wise-assery, but I did say it to a nosy woman who used to be a friend of mine until she started asking questions like that and telling other friends I'm a bully and a gold-digger for "forcing" Hubby to live this way. In reality, all of it, from opening the marriage to Guy and me transitioning from friends-with-benefits to actual lovers with the emphasis on *love*, was Hubby's suggestion, based on what he perceived would benefit me that I didn't dare to ask for.)
__________________
Me: 44, cis-het female, poly
Hubby: my husband, 42, monogamous
S2: my "attachment", male, 44, undetermined
Best Friend: male, 38, platonic; the one who keeps me sane through all this!
My daughters: Alt (age 19) and Country (age 16)
S2's sons: Spikes (age 9) and Beads (age 6)
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 07-29-2014, 11:59 PM
kdt26417's Avatar
kdt26417 kdt26417 is online now
Official Greeter
 
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Yelm, Washington
Posts: 6,680
Default

I'm sure I won't be able to remember *all* of the arguments against polyamory I've ever heard, but I'll list as many of them as I can remember at this time.
  • Polyamory is a sin. It displeases God.
  • God made us to be paired off as man-woman couples.
  • People who practice polyamory will go to Hell.
  • Polyamory is an unhealthy relationship practice.
  • Since people are naturally jealous, polyamory is impractical and unworkable.
  • Polyamory is misogynistic; it's designed to indulge men's irresponsible urge to have a harem.
  • People practice polyamory because they can't handle commitment.
  • Polyamory is just a fancy word for cheating.
  • Polyamory violates the sacred marital vows.
  • Polyamorists are sex addicts.
  • Polyamorous people are naturally selfish, and like to use the cool-sounding word "polyamory" to make themselves seem noble.
  • People pretend like they're practicing polyamory to help their kids, when the truth is, they're just being selfish.
  • Polyamory is a cruel dynamic to introduce to your struggling monogamous spouse.
  • People practice polyamory to run away from their marital problems.
  • Polyamory destroys families.
  • Polyamory is bad for the kids.
  • Polyamory is an awful example to set for your children.
  • Polyamorists force their partners and their poly ideals onto their children.
  • People spring polyamory on their kids when the kids are teens, completely turning their lives upside-down.
  • Polyamorists out themselves and their kids to the world, resulting in the kids getting bullied at school.
  • Polyamorists homeschool their kids instead of letting them have a normal upbringing.
  • Children do best in a home with their natural parents, one father and one mother.
  • Kids don't want an extra mommy or an extra daddy.
  • You permanently damage your kids each time a new poly partner cycles into and out of their lives.
  • Your time, energy, and resources are finite. So adding an extra partner means somebody will have to pay for it -- most likely your spouse and/or your kids.
My rebuttals:
  • Re: polyamory is a sin. It displeases God ... unproven. God hasn't said that to us in person, and you can't prove that the Bible is the word of God. (In fact I'd expect polyamorous ideals to be pleasing to God.)
  • Re: God made us to be paired off as man-woman couples ... unproven. Same reasons as above argument. (In fact no one would have gay or poly inclinations if that argument were true.)
  • Re: people who practice polyamory will go to Hell ... unproven. Same reasons as above argument. (In fact we shouldn't expect Hell to exist in a cosmos governed by a loving God.)
  • Re: polyamory is an unhealthy relationship practice ... unproven. Not yet adequately tested. My observation is that some poly relationships are carried out well, while others are carried out poorly.
  • Re: since people are naturally jealous, polyamory is impractical and unworkable ... unproven. Not yet adequately tested. My observation is that many people learn to manage their jealousies quite well. Some people even seem to be immune to jealousy.
  • Re: polyamory is misogynistic; it's designed to indulge men's irresponsible urge to have a harem ... unproven. What evidence we have actually indicates that polyamory was primarily invented by women, for women.
  • Re: people practice polyamory because they can't handle commitment ... first of all, commitment doesn't necessarily mean "til death do us part." Secondly, many polyamorists do stay together (especially in groups of three) for life.
  • Re: polyamory is just a fancy word for cheating ... only if cheating includes arrangements that have the full knowledge and consent of all participants.
  • Re: polyamory violates the sacred marital vows ... a couple can have a traditional wedding, then agree later that they want to revise the vows they made to each other.
  • Re: polyamorists are sex addicts ... unproven. My observation is that most polyamorists are getting about the same amount of sex as most monogamists.
  • Re: polyamorous people are naturally selfish, and like to use the cool-sounding word "polyamory" to make themselves seem noble ... some selfish people do use the word "polyamory" as an excuse. But I know many polyamorists who really are noble.
  • Re: people pretend like they're practicing polyamory to help their kids, when the truth is, they're just being selfish ... unproven. In fact I've never heard a polyamorist cite the kids as his/her main reason for practicing polyamory, although many polyamorists do believe that it's good for the kids.
  • Re: polyamory is a cruel dynamic to introduce to your struggling monogamous spouse ... it can be in some cases, and polyamory is not for everyone. But sometimes it has to do with whether the polyamorous spouse makes due efforts to meet the needs of the monogamous spouse.
  • Re: people practice polyamory to run away from their marital problems ... some do, yes, and when they do, it causes all kinds of problems. Common poly wisdom urges us to tend to our original relationship and not just throw ourselves into a new relationship.
  • Re: polyamory destroys families ... it can if it's done poorly, but I've just as often seen polyamory save families.
  • Re: polyamory is bad for the kids ... it can be especially if it's done poorly, but I've just as often seen polyamory benefit the kids.
  • Re: polyamory is an awful example to set for your children ... it is if it's done poorly, but I've just as often seen it serve as a good example for the kids.
  • Re: polyamorists force their partners and their poly ideals onto their children ... some do and they shouldn't. Most I know of give their kids an age-appropriate level of autonomy.
  • Re: people spring polyamory on their kids when the kids are teens, completely turning their lives upside-down ... some do, but I've heard of polyamory introduced to the kids at any age (about equally often) from toddler to adult.
  • Re: polyamorists out themselves and their kids to the world, resulting in the kids getting bullied at school ... some do and they shouldn't. They should let the kids have a say in that. I've also observed, though, that lots of kids do just fine at school even when their classmates know.
  • Re: polyamorists homeschool their kids instead of letting them have a normal upbringing ... some polyamorists homeschool, but plenty of others send their kids to public school. Of those that homeschool, I've only heard good reports, including efforts to give the kids opportunities to socialize with other kids from other families.
  • Re: children do best in a home with their natural parents, one father and one mother ... unproven. In fact, considerable evidence exists that kids raised by a same-sex couple virtually always do well, and the majority of poly kids I know of do well also.
  • Re: kids don't want an extra mommy or an extra daddy ... sometimes true and the kids should have the say as to whether they relate to an additional adult as an additional parent. But that doesn't invalidate polyamory.
  • Re: you permanently damage your kids each time a new poly partner cycles into and out of their lives ... first, it depends on how well the kids get to know each partner. Second, most kids have schoolteachers, friends, babysitters, grandparents, etc., that cycle in and out of their lives. Third, many poly units are poly-fi and remain quite stable over the years.
  • Re: your time, energy, and resources are finite. So adding an extra partner means somebody will have to pay for it -- most likely your spouse and/or your kids ... absolutely true and one of the reasons why poly isn't right for everyone. Those who do practice poly need to manage their time considerately and wisely. But I know of many poly people who do just that.
No doubt I'll think of more arguments against poly but I won't torture you with a longer list.

There are many reasons why polyamory can go badly (just as there are many reasons why monogamy can go badly). At the top of the list, probably, is the failure to productively communicate. Dishonesty, a lack of empathy, and failure to practice safe sex are a few other common downfalls for polyamory. But, that's one of the reasons forums like Polyamory.com exist: to help polyamorists avoid the pitfalls. And many polyamorists do avoid the pitfalls. Of those that don't, many come out alright in the end in spite of all that.
__________________
Love means never having to say, "Put down that meat cleaver!"
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 07-30-2014, 02:20 AM
PolyinPractice PolyinPractice is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2013
Posts: 519
Default

I've heard the same ones over and over, and they're all stupid.

1) Isn't it cheating?
No.

2) Don't you feel jealous?
No.

3) Isn't poly immoral?
Why?

4) Doesn't it hurt the children?
Extended families and village communities that raised children never hurt them. Why would this?
Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 07-30-2014, 02:37 AM
mischa mischa is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2014
Posts: 25
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kdt26417 View Post
  • Since people are naturally jealous, polyamory is impractical and unworkable.
"Since people are naturally aggressive, getting along / absence of violence is unachievable."

That's an analogy to how the argument looks to me. Naturally, some people are more prone to some emotions, but ultimately managing one's emotions is not only workable, but necessary and convenient. It's ultimately your decision whether desiring / loving multiple people, or jealousy, is something you want to encourage or restrain. It's not set on stone.

- - -

And there is no god so any argument involving god makes no sense to me...

Quote:
Originally Posted by kdt26417 View Post
"Some people even seem to be immune to jealousy."
I am one of those, particularly in the love department.

Last edited by mischa; 07-30-2014 at 02:44 AM.
Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 07-30-2014, 03:24 AM
Vinccenzo Vinccenzo is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 343
Default

I've only come up against one argument that I couldn't quite dispute.

It takes effort to build a healthy relationship with even just one partner. The effort involved in building a healthy relationship with more than one partner can cause instability for all involved. How can you have children and put them through the potential unheaval all this might reap? Its not fair to them seeing as they have no power to leave the situation should things get ugly.
I still don't know how to answer that one other than by adhering to a heavy primary/secondary model till children become adults.
Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 07-30-2014, 04:48 PM
MsChristy's Avatar
MsChristy MsChristy is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2013
Location: East Coast
Posts: 87
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by poly6 View Post
How do you hide this from your parents? Don't they ever come to visit or anything?
Actually, no, my parents have never visited me. They live over 500 miles away and my mom has had extensive health problems. That being said, even if I lived in the same town as them, they still would not know. My parents are conservative Christians that believe in traditional family values. I love my parents, and while they do know we don't see eye to eye on some things, I honestly worry they would stop communicating with me if they found out.

My other partner also does not live with us, he lives in a different state. While my husband and I will eventually move to his town, I still do not see my parents finding out.

In a perfect world, yeah, I would be able to be out. But at this time I still want to have a relationship with my folks.
__________________
--------------------------------------------------
MsChristy- married female
C-my husband
H-my partner
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT. The time now is 11:23 PM.