I currently identify as a Reform Jew, though I feel a strong pull towards Reconstructionist Judaism (I like keeping to more of the old laws, but paired with a very "liberal" lifestyle).
The boyfriend is a Catholic convert. Previously he was an Asatru priest, of all things (Karma, you should know that there is actually an Asatru Church who use that old Norse word to specifically refer to the fact that they worship the traditional Norse gods so if you use it to identify yourself in certain circles, people will be VERY confused when you talk about your affinity with Coyote and Kali and the like).
The boyfriend's wife is a Lutheran and my husband is an atheist. So ... only one former pagan and one atheist and three practicing Judeo-Christians.